SamiJo's Pizzeria

By far the best pizza and people in town! The owners are incredible nice and are dedicate to serving the best food accompanied by great customer service. The is not just a pizza place but a place that feels like home. My boyfriend and I use to visit very often and recently went back since we were in the area and the owner remembered us! I recommend this to anyone looking for great pizza and a great place to go and enjoy with the whole family! If I could give it 10 stars I would.

Samijo's is one of the best pizzas I've had. My favorite pizza place closed down during covid and I was at a serious loss of a good joint with good food. Sami's has always delivered. The vibe inside is always welcoming and friendly. This business deserves all the praises and is quickly becoming my family's favorite friday night go to. Thanks to all who work there and deliver evrey time!

This is my second time here, the first time was a carry out and it wasSO good that I came back with my wife to dine in house. We both agree that this is the freshest, best tasting pizza around. The restaurant is CLEAN and had a lovely atmosphere. The owner is a pleasure and the service is spectacular. Y'all have to come here. THIS PLACE IS GREAT!

The only real pizza crust in the Jefferson fort Atkinson area. Hands down the best pizza in Jefferson Fort Atkinson area - everywhere else has the same Frozen crust Chicken tenders are also fantastic - the golden sauces out of this world Super friendly service, fast and delicious!

This is by far the best pizza in the area! The crust is crisp with the right chew and not overly heavy! We had the Philly Cheese steak. It did not dissapoint! Cute seating on the inside and it also has patio seating outside! You can get pizza by the slice as well! A must try for pizza lovers!!

Okay, so I've been meaning to do a review on this place. So my fiance, his mom, and I went to SamiJo's Pizzeria I wanna say in Oct. So yeah I am late on this review. Anyways, we've been wanting to try this place out. And we were happy that we did! I believe it's fairly new. It was new for us. The pictures I will be posting are from 3 different times we were there. It was so good we actually went back like 3 times in one week. And the owners and staff were so welcoming and greeted us when we walked in. The ordering is different from other places I've been to. You pick where you want to sit. Menus are on the tables. And when you're ready you go to the register and order. Which is so different! It's pretty cool they do that. And one is when my daughter came to visit us. She and her boyfriend moved back in August. They now live in St Paul, MN. So we took her there and she couldn't get over how good the pizza was! She can eat a lot and not gain weight. My daughter and fiance ate that pizza like there was no tomorrow. She said it's better than Gus Pizza which is saying something. I was like you just didn't say that lol. She did. It's cool how now they know us when we go and eat there. And the gentleman always asks how my daughter is doing. The reason their pizza is so good it's because of the crust. It's crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. We overheard a girl saying that her boyfriend is from New York. And misses the pizzas there. They went there before and he said that the pizza is close to how they make them in New York. I highly recommend going there and try their pizzas and other foods on the menu. We say we're going to try something else. But the pizza is so good. So like 3 years ago I had COVID when it was going around. I still don't have my scent of restaurant food in general and anything else. So I can't tell you if it smells good or not. My daughter and fiance said that it smells great. Be safe everyone! And cheers

We were in the area for a graduation and decided to try this pizza. Locals recommended. It did not disappoint! Delicious New York style. We got the xl pepperoni along with garlic bread for our family of five. It was the perfect amount of food. We loved the pizza, we liked the garlic bread, but it was a little too crumbly to eat in our hotel room. We would probably get something other than the garlic bread next time, but really glad we ordered from here.

I may have exclaimed “oh yeah!” loudly enough to startle my family when I opened the pizza box lid....and I may have shed a little tear of pure delight when I took a bite of my white pie (and the subsequent eggplant parm & margherita we also got)....coming from the NYC metro area to WI, it’s been a quest to find pizza that nails both the toppings AND crust we miss from out east...SamiJo’s knocks it outta the park on both. Absolutely cannot wait to go back and try other offerings. PS: pro tip, add ricotta to your white pie to really send it over the edge